video-accessibility/backend/tests/unit/test_websocket_org_isolation.py
Vadym Samoilenko b427ee9f49 fix(authz): MT-3/6/7/8 org isolation + P1 English-first QC enforcement
Multi-tenancy isolation (P0):
- MT-3: Add get_job_or_403 (org membership check) to all 19+ job action endpoints
- MT-6: Same gate added to all review_notes (5) and vtt_versions (4) handlers
- MT-7: WebSocket /ws/jobs/{job_id} closes with 4403 on org mismatch;
  /ws/jobs passes accessible_org_ids to ConnectionManager; server-side
  keepalive at 20 s (asyncio.wait_for timeout) prevents proxy idle drops
- MT-8: list_users scoped to org memberships for non-platform-admins

WebSocket fixes (Mod Comms 2026-03-18 incident):
- Frontend heartbeat lowered 30 000 → 20 000 ms (was at Apache timeout edge)
- Terminal close codes 4001/4003/4004/4403 no longer trigger reconnect loop
- Silently discard server "keepalive" frames alongside existing "pong"

English-first QC (P1):
- _assert_can_approve blocks target language approval until source is APPROVED
- PRODUCTION/ADMIN roles bypass the gate
- Source VTT edits reset stale APPROVED/PENDING_REVIEW/IN_REVIEW target states

Tests (all passing):
- backend/tests/unit/test_language_qc_english_first.py (15 cases)
- backend/tests/unit/test_routes_jobs_org_isolation.py (12 cases)
- backend/tests/unit/test_review_notes_org_isolation.py (16 parametrized cases)
- backend/tests/unit/test_vtt_versions_org_isolation.py (16 parametrized cases)
- backend/tests/unit/test_websocket_org_isolation.py (11 cases)
- backend/tests/unit/test_admin_users_org_filter.py (7 cases)
- frontend: useJobStatusWebSocket.terminal.test.ts (9 cases)
- frontend: useJobStatusWebSocket.heartbeat.test.ts (9 cases)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-05-01 11:43:10 +01:00

148 lines
5.9 KiB
Python

"""
WebSocket org isolation tests (MT-7).
Tests _can_access_org helper and the org-check logic baked into the
websocket_job_status handler. Uses unit-level testing of the helpers
rather than spinning up a full ASGI server.
"""
from unittest.mock import AsyncMock, MagicMock
import pytest
from app.api.v1.routes_websockets import _can_access_org
# ── _can_access_org helper ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────
class TestCanAccessOrg:
def test_platform_admin_none_memberships_always_true(self):
assert _can_access_org("org-x", None) is True
def test_none_org_id_always_true(self):
"""Legacy job with no org_id — pass through (further checks done in handler)."""
assert _can_access_org(None, {}) is True
assert _can_access_org(None, {"org-a": "member"}) is True
def test_org_in_memberships_returns_true(self):
from app.models.organization import OrgRole
memberships = {"org-a": OrgRole.MEMBER, "org-b": OrgRole.OWNER}
assert _can_access_org("org-a", memberships) is True
assert _can_access_org("org-b", memberships) is True
def test_org_not_in_memberships_returns_false(self):
from app.models.organization import OrgRole
memberships = {"org-a": OrgRole.MEMBER}
assert _can_access_org("org-b", memberships) is False
assert _can_access_org("org-c", memberships) is False
def test_empty_memberships_returns_false_for_any_org(self):
assert _can_access_org("org-x", {}) is False
def test_string_memberships_dict_accepted(self):
"""_can_access_org only uses `in` operator — any dict-like works."""
memberships = {"org-a": "member"}
assert _can_access_org("org-a", memberships) is True
assert _can_access_org("org-b", memberships) is False
# ── Org close-code logic ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────
class TestWebSocketOrgCloseCode:
"""
Verify that the handler emits 4403 for org-denied jobs by simulating
the relevant logic path with mocks.
"""
@pytest.mark.asyncio
async def test_org_denied_closes_with_4403(self):
"""When _can_access_org returns False, handler must close with code 4403."""
# Simulate the decision: user is in org-a, job is in org-b
job_org = "org-b"
memberships = {"org-a": "member"} # org-b not in memberships
can_access = _can_access_org(job_org, memberships)
assert can_access is False
# Simulate what the handler does:
mock_websocket = MagicMock()
mock_websocket.close = AsyncMock()
if not can_access:
await mock_websocket.close(code=4403, reason="Org access denied")
mock_websocket.close.assert_called_once_with(code=4403, reason="Org access denied")
@pytest.mark.asyncio
async def test_org_allowed_does_not_close(self):
"""When _can_access_org returns True, handler proceeds to connect."""
job_org = "org-a"
memberships = {"org-a": "member"}
can_access = _can_access_org(job_org, memberships)
assert can_access is True
mock_websocket = MagicMock()
mock_websocket.close = AsyncMock()
if not can_access:
await mock_websocket.close(code=4403, reason="Org access denied")
mock_websocket.close.assert_not_called()
@pytest.mark.asyncio
async def test_platform_admin_none_memberships_not_denied(self):
"""Platform admin (memberships=None) always passes org check."""
job_org = "org-any"
memberships = None # platform admin
can_access = _can_access_org(job_org, memberships)
assert can_access is True
mock_websocket = MagicMock()
mock_websocket.close = AsyncMock()
if not can_access:
await mock_websocket.close(code=4403, reason="Org access denied")
mock_websocket.close.assert_not_called()
# ── Keepalive constants ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
class TestWebSocketKeepAliveInterval:
def test_keepalive_interval_is_20_seconds(self):
"""
Interval must be ≤20s to stay under Apache mod_proxy_wstunnel idle timeout.
Mod Comms 2026-03-18: 25s was insufficient; 20s is safe.
"""
from app.api.v1.routes_websockets import _KEEPALIVE_INTERVAL_S
assert _KEEPALIVE_INTERVAL_S == 20
def test_terminal_close_codes_include_4403(self):
from app.api.v1.routes_websockets import _TERMINAL_CLOSE_CODES
assert 4403 in _TERMINAL_CLOSE_CODES
assert 4001 in _TERMINAL_CLOSE_CODES
assert 4003 in _TERMINAL_CLOSE_CODES
assert 4004 in _TERMINAL_CLOSE_CODES
# ── Job list accessible_org_ids filter ────────────────────────────────────────
class TestJobListOrgFilter:
def test_non_admin_gets_accessible_org_ids_list(self):
"""
For /ws/jobs, accessible_org_ids must be the list of the user's org IDs.
Platform admins pass None (unrestricted).
"""
from app.models.organization import OrgRole
memberships = {"org-a": OrgRole.MEMBER, "org-b": OrgRole.OWNER}
accessible_org_ids = list(memberships.keys())
assert set(accessible_org_ids) == {"org-a", "org-b"}
def test_platform_admin_gets_none_accessible_org_ids(self):
"""Platform admin memberships=None → accessible_org_ids=None (unrestricted)."""
memberships = None
accessible_org_ids = None if memberships is None else list(memberships.keys())
assert accessible_org_ids is None